PDA

View Full Version : Butterflies Aren't Free - Maureen Dowd


Rita
05-07-2008, 12:10 PM
.

I miss Molly Ivans but have recently been enjoying Maureen Dowd:


Butterflies Aren’t Free by Maureen Dowd (excerpt)

.................................. Just as Obama spent his youth trying not to be threatening, so as not to unnerve whites, Hillary spent her life learning to be threatening so she could beat back challenges to her and her husband — from Republicans and from “bimbo eruptions” and now from a charmed younger rival.

As Obama learned to accommodate, the accommodating Hillary learned to triangulate and lacerate. As he learned that following the rules could get you far with adoring mentors, she learned from Bill and Dick Morris and Mark Penn that following the rules was for saps...............................

The Democratic race has been a scorpion and a butterfly in a bottle. Hillary tore Barry’s wings off, and so psyched him out with her silly goading — “Enough about the speeches and the big rallies!” she cried — that he gave up his magical trump cards..............................

It’s hard to believe that this Hillary is the same Wellesley girl who said she yearned for a more “ecstatic and penetrating mode of living.” What would that young Hillary — who volunteered on Gene McCarthy’s anti-war campaign; who cried the day Martin Luther King Jr. was killed; who referred to some of her “smorgasbord of personalities” in a 1967 letter to a friend as an “alienated academic,” and an “involved pseudo-hippie”; who once returned a bottle of perfume after feeling guilty about the poverty around her — think of this shape-shifting, cynical Hillary?
She’s so at odds with who she used to be, even in the Senate, that if she were to get elected, who would voters be electing?
Obama is like her idealistic, somewhat naïve self before the world launched 1,000 attacks against her, turning her into the hard-bitten, driven politician who has launched 1,000 attacks against Obama.

As she makes a last frenzied and likely futile attempt to crush the butterfly, it’s as though she’s crushing the remnants of her own girlish innocence. - Maureen Dowd

link:
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/05/07/opinion/07dowd.html?ex=1210824000&en=973b77a4ca546444&ei=5070&emc=eta1




.

Mermaid
05-07-2008, 10:48 PM
I am by no means a Hillary fan, but I think it's patently unfair of Maureen Dowd to complain that she's not the girl she used to be. Life changes people. Growing older changes people. Experiences change people. None of us are static, or I should hope not, because not changing means not growing. If Maureen Dowd doesn't like Hillary's politics, that's her perogative. But to whine about how she's not "the same Wellesley girl" she was how many decades ago is a little ridiculous.